Design on Trial · Abitare

Page from issue 493 of Abitare

Konstantin Grcic’s 360ºC chair for Magis is a product that defies classification. It’s a chair that doesn’t look like anything we have around us these days. It’s a bit like stool, but it has a sort of a small back. It looks hard, but it’s actually much softer to the touch than one would thing. As with other of Grcic’s creations, it doesn’t look pretty, luxurious or particularly comfortable.

After it was launched in Milan this year, the 360º chair received a considerable amount of press, but I would say only got two relevant, considerably different reviews. Sam Jacob’s brilliantly funny and insightful review in the September 2009 issue of icon magazine highlighted the chair’s physical and mental impact on the user: “Sitting here is conceived as an active state – a constant psychological state of agitation.”

Abitare approached it from a very different angle: taking advantage of the chair’s April launch in Milan, it gathered not only the designer and manufacturer to talk about it, but also called other people to the discussion, which it called “design trial”. Placing the 360º chair as the defendant, Abitare design and architecture editor Anniina Koivu called American designer Jonathan Olivares for the prosecution, MoMA’s curator of architecture and design Paola Antonelli as the defense attorney. The chair’s designer Konstantin Grcic and manufacturer Eugenio Perazza (Magis’ charismatic CEO) were called in as witnesses.

The court session can be seen in part on YouTube; its transcript was published in June of 2009 in the printed version of Abitare and can be read in its entirety on the magazine’s website – where there is even the option of downloading a pdf of the article’s pages. This is an extremely entertaining and thought-provoking piece of design criticism. The chair is placed in its historical, use and environmental context; it’s talked about as if it was a real, living being, as it is accused – particularly on the environmental impact of its parts and materials – and defended – the strongest arguments being it’s a new way of sitting and a new interpretation of office furniture. In the end, the defendant is found “Not Guilty”.

Design on trial is a phenomenal, engaging way to observe and critique designed objects – and I assume it would also work for built environments – that goes well beyond the usual test-based review. So far Abitare has not published another design trial, but I look forward to the next court session.

I wrote this post as an assignment for the ‘New New Media’ D-Crit course, taught by Elizabeth Spiers. This was supposed to be a segment of a larger assignment, called Reading Room, an online venue for discussion and critique of design and architecture magazines. This post and the Metropolis magazine post were examples of content created for different sections of this website. This one is dedicated to innovative magazine sections and writing formats, the other to the design and redesign of magazine. Other sections include “Popular Subjects” (where one subject, product of person that having widespread coverage in magazines around the world would be regularly picked in order to analyze/discuss the way it has been talked about offline and online) and Editors, dedicated to the figure of the magazine (something I’m quite obsessed about) and how a publication can become a mirror of its editor’s personality and preoccupations, or completely  change from one editor’s tenure to the next. This section would be made up of a series of interviews with living editors on how they do what they do, and discover the people, the work and the legacy of historic and influential past editors. Reading Room would actually be something I’d like to actually turn into a reality, but maybe when I’m done with my thesis



8 Comments

  1. sir designalot wrote:

    Grcic’s chair is part of a design trend called “the New Fuglies”

  2. 360 degree chair? Doesnt look very comfortable. But very functionable.

  3. Hi,. I have a question that I hope will have a simple answer. I have a wordpress blog and right now my side navigation menu is on the right side. I would like for the menu to be on the left side. Can someone please tell me how I would go about doing this, in simple terms, please? . . Or point me in the direction of a resource that tells me how to do it?. . Thanks so much ya’ll!.

  4. Ellis Tkacz wrote:

    that everything you need to know about it can be found here: http://www.w3.org/

  5. Edwardo Gatch wrote:

    My state registered company serves as a subsidiary for a webdesign company in Hungary. The contracted relation

  6. Antonio Ellis wrote:

    I simply adore your site WOW! I had a great idea for your interesting blog my friend :). I’m a blogger too and I spend a lot of time making and reading sites like simples » Blog Archive » Design on Trial · Abitare all day. I used to just waste my energy making a few bucks here and there from google adsense but i found something SO much more powerful and better. After learning the proper way to rank and get visitors (so easy it’s hard) $348.15 $$CASH$$ in the last 3 days just days after modifying my blogs. Can you imagine how floored I was? Here is where I learned all my tricks—> http://bit.ly/qz64MC <—Just giving your site a look I can tell you'll probably pull in a few hundred bucks a month if you modify just a little code. I hope that it serves you well and you have all my blessings. Cheers! Antonio Ellis

  7. Law Directory wrote:

    Hey there and thank you for this info on legal issues. I’ve definitely picked up something new from right here. I did however expertise several technical issues using the website, as I experienced to reload the web site lots of times previous to I could get it to load properly. I had been wondering if your server is OK?

  8. five mistakes wrote:

    Your site is really interesting to me and your topics are very relevant. I was browsing around and came across something you might find interesting. I was guilty of 3 of them with my sites. “99% of site owners are guilty of these 5 mistakes”. http://tinyurl.com/cwa3tj7 You will be suprised how easy they are to fix.