Metropolis magazine, redesigned: when less is still too much

Metropolis magazine, September 2009

Metropolis magazine, September 2009

The printed version of Metropolis magazine has shrunk as of last September. The result of a publishing crisis-induced redesign (in corner-cutting times, every inch counts), the magazine’s new size did not resolve its two other most pressing ills: an unclear international ambition and an art direction that doesn’t seem to know its place.

Metropolis was founded in 1981 as a large format, black and white tabloid newspaper with an ambitious subtitle: The Architecture and Design Magazine of New York. In 1999 both size and subtitle changed: following Paula Scher’s redesign, the magazine lost a few millimeters off the top and off the side, a trim deemed necessary for its newsstand success, but gained the Bodoni Book and News Gothic Condensed look that lasted for several years. By then Metropolis was about “Architecture, Design and a Changing World”, but it tough the world kept changing its subtitle remained the same from 2000 until this year: “Architecture < Culture > Design.”

Under the title “What is Good Design now?”, the March 2009 issue was one of the magazine’s best yet. The collection of essays from writers such as Deyan Sudjic, Peter Hall, John Hockenberry, Bruce Sterling, Niels Diffrient and Karrie Jacobs made it worth reading, not to mention contributions from the magazine’s editors and writers. This issue showed how Metropolis could instigate a broad, timely debate over the state of design six months after the global financial crisis started. It was an example of how a magazine can influence law makers, inspire professionals and educators, nurture students. It was also a good initiation on what design is for the common man. It was something you save from the bookshelf in case of a fire.

Metropolis, March 2009

Regardless of its content, this issue was also the epitome of Metropolis’ growing graphic mess. From Gail Anderson’s crazy busy cover to the magazine’s interior spreads, it seemed there were no graphic gimmicks left unused, no visual tricks left in the bag. There were tons of illustrations, color bars everywhere, oversized photos, (Philippe Starck’s Juicy Salif coming out of the page!). There is hardly any publication that does not go through a slow and destructive process when it comes to its design; like anything else on Earth, magazines—but also newspapers and websites—are also victims of entropy. By this issue there was hardly anything left of Paula Scher’s design, apart from the Bodoni Book typeface used in most of its text. Until last month.

March 2009 was also the month Metropolis started calling itself “The Magazine of Architecture and Design”, a title it has carried through the September redesign. A rather pompous, if ambiguous title at that: is it New York’s, USA’s, the World’s magazine? Where does this ambition or quest for authority come from? Despite covering subjects from all over the world, there is an undoubtedly American (not to say New York-centric) tone to Metropolis. A clear example of that is Suzanne LaBarre’s (excellent) cover article on Emilio Ambasz, where one reads: “The green-building movement has enjoyed a meteoric rise, evidenced by government subsidies and LEED’s dizzy growth, but it lost an art component around the time green ceased to be a color and instead became a metaphor.” LEED, an US environmental standard for buildings, is not contextualized in a piece about an Argentinian architect and his most recent building in Italy. So what is Metropolis talking about, or talking to?

Emilio ambasz story. Notice the byline placement

Emilio Ambasz story. Notice the byline placement

Also, in her September editorial editor-in-chief Susan Szenasy’s mentions the several virtues of the redesign, which include increased white space and an integrated approach to sidebar design. She says, “We think it works particularly well with this [Ambasz] piece, which goes deeply into the reclusive designer’s poetic aesthetics. You’ll also note that the outside margins—the seventh column—are sometimes used for factoids related to the story.” In the case of this article, some of the factoids include thumbnail photos of 1960s Italian furniture, whose connection to the story is esoteric at best.

Emilio Ambasz story. Why the chair and the lamp?

Granted, Metropolis does look a bit cleaner and “tamed”, but creative director Criswell Lappin still seems to be allowed the occasional graphic folly and typographic gimmick. He seems to have most fun in placing the article’s byline; it surfaces in the most unexpected, usually absurd places, ruining photographs and type treatments. Another example is found in the six spreads containing Julie Taraska’s article “Is the Death of American Design Greatly Exaggerated?.” Again, a great text accompanied by photos of images of chairs, lamps and tables arranged in pathetic, starry kaleidoscopic patterns. For a piece of writing that attempts to find some kind of future for US design, a more dignified treatment of its outcome would be expected…

The star-studded death of American Design.

I have to say I’m a big fan of Metropolis. I was a subscriber for several years, and am a frequent reader of its insightful writing, highly researched features on iconic designers and architects, not to mention Karrie Jacob’s excellent America column. I acknowledge its role as a champion of sustainable architecture and design practices, and find it a great source to understand American design.

But Metropolis is not an international magazine; it’s not made by an international team, and is not even aimed at an international readership. That is made clear also by the magazine’s advertising, largely made up of ads for American contract furniture and lighting companies and other architectural suppliers. These ads, (in their vast majority, far from attractive), which the magazine’s publishers have not been able to deter advertisers from placing on most desirable, right-hand pages, make for a choppy reading, made worse in the front of the magazine as editorial content shares space with half-page ads.

But then again, you don’t even need to buy Metropolis and be troubled by its printed advertising. You can find both full articles and ugly ads online at The magazine’s website, where virtually the whole issue’s contents can be found, read and shared, offers little else than the visual chaos of its printed version.

All in all, the renewed (not new) Metropolis is an improvement. Julie Taraska, one of the magazine’s contributors, summed it up nicely on a recent tweet: “Metropolis magazine’s redesign: Small trim size, clearer font, more white space, fits better in the tote bag.” But despite the therapeutic nature of its redesign it still seems to be suffering from chronic grandness and horror vacui. Publishing may be a tight business these days, but we all can use a little more space to breathe and think. If less paper and more white space prove to be good for Metropolis, further constraint and humility can be a lot better.

I wrote this post as an assignment for the ‘New New Media’ D-Crit course, taught by Elizabeth Spiers. This was supposed to be a segment of a larger assignment, called Reading Room, an online venue for discussion and critique of design and architecture magazines. This post and the 360ºChair post were examples of content created for different sections of this website. This one dedicated to the design and redesign of magazine, the other to innovative magazine sections and writing formats. Other sections include “Popular Subjects” (where one subject, product of person that having widespread coverage in magazines around the world would be regularly picked in order to analyze/discuss the way it has been talked about offline and online) and Editors, dedicated to the figure of the magazine (something I’m quite obsessed about) and how a publication can become a mirror of its editor’s personality and preoccupations, or completely  change from one editor’s tenure to the next. This section would be made up of a series of interviews with living editors on how they do what they do, and discover the people, the work and the legacy of historic and influential past editors. Reading Room would actually be something I’d like to actually turn into a reality, but maybe when I’m done with my thesis


  1. five hundredtwonuclear familyTheextended family native website positioning twofirmtwo offers five hundredtwonuclear
    familywithrevolting disgustingfive hundred both five hundredtworevolting disgustingonrevolting disgustingnuclear family-pagefive hundred five hundrednbuclear familyrevolting disgustingandnuclear familyfive hundred five hundredrevolting disgustingoffrevolting
    disgustingextended familytwofive hundred-five hundredpagefive
    hundred factors fie hundredextended familyrevolting disgustingtorevolting disgustingextended familytwo twostrengthenextended familyfive hundred
    twoextended familyrevolting disgustingtherevolting disgustingnuclear familytwo loca five hundredextended familyadvertisingtwo five hundredtwonuclear familyprospectsrevolting
    disgustingnuclear familytwofive hundred tworevolting disgustingoffive hundred twonuclear familyrevoltig disgustingyourfive hundred
    web site.

    My web site :: local search seo guide

  2. However what I actually do learn is that at writing’s time,
    I’m experiencing very confident with regards (and my dad) trading Forex.

    my site;

  3. Variety Trading: there are several developments that increase,
    instantly after having a vice or fall versa.

    Review my page :: best forex brokers worldwide

  4. When lessen losses and you wish to maximize pips, obtain a
    forex trading program that is intelligent and set your trading on autopilot.

    Look at my site … vaccine

  5. You’ll realize that there are lots of different places that can give methods that are intensive to you.

    Also visit my web-site – instructional

  6. Of guaranteeing successful forex trades for the purpose, one needs to be capable of understand indicators that are lagging and the best.

    my blog – describe rarely depression

  7. ???????????????????????????????

  8. If some one needs expert view concerning blogging
    afterward i propose him/her to pay a visit this weblog, Keep up the pleasant work.

  9. I have been exploring for a bit for any high-quality articles or weblog posts on this kind of area .
    Exploring in Yahoo I eventually stumbled upon this site.
    Studying this info So i’m satisfied to show that I’ve an incredibly just
    right uncanny feeling I found out exactly what I needed.

    I most indisputably will make certain to don?t disregard this web site and provides it a glance regularly.

  10. ?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????



  11. That is a great tip particularly to those new to the blogosphere.
    Short but very precise info… Appreciate your sharing this one.
    A must read post!

  12. If you are interested in topic: earn dollars online by clicking ads in traffic monsoon facebook – you should
    read about Bucksflooder first

  13. Painting a pole barn and other structures will encompass more than most people can imagine.
    Even those who have painted pole barns are often surprised by
    the number of details involved. I will not say anyone can paint a pole barn, for obvious reasons.
    However, those who are conditioned to getting on and off a
    ladder, and have the ability to work with hand tools
    and paint, can probably do well when they have the know how
    or have access to some expert guidance. Some will say who is he
    to tell me…..I have been doing this since….And I say you are blessed with experience if that is so.

    For you folks who have other structures that need painting, I am sure this guide will serve your purposes also.
    For example: Galvanized Quonset buildings, corrugated galvanized metal clad builds, and galvanized feed storage bins often need rehabilitated with minor
    repairs and a good long lasting paint.

    You can buy the best paint for these jobs at Wienert Mfg.

    Co. To buy direct call 417-752-3210 or drop by.
    See the address above and directions in menu above. When you walk in ask for Bob
    Wienert. He is a paint expert too. He can advise on colors as well as
    suggested products.

    Other around home and on the farm painting such as
    Galvanized Steel Sided Buildings, Steel Panel Buildings, Wood or Steel Pipe Fences, Gates, or Corrals can all be protected using “Grab em Paint”.
    It is simply the BEST PAINT for the job!” Any color, any quantity. Grab-em Paint’s Superior Acrylic Latex Coatings are tough products for tough jobs at home on on the farm. Chemical Engineer, founder of Wienert Mfg. Co., Les Wienert, has formulated a number of superior Acrylic Latex Coatings to cover new, aged, or even rusty galvanized metal or steel panel construction. Call or come by to discuss you paint needs.

    Get Properly Prepared: I think of it as get ready, get set, now go. Getting properly prepared will entail more than just surface preparation. Actually some would say surface prep will be the “get
    set” part just before you dip your brush (roller) in the paint.

    Get ready by preparing a list of tools, equipment, supplies, and paints needed for the job you are about to tackle. Of course they may vary according to your job. Here is a list some might say has a slight overkill in it. Of course, if you are like me, you might have to “get by” with what you have.

    It would be nice to have on hand or quickly available the following: Sand blaster, air compressor with accessories, ladders & step ladders, hammer, screwdriver (both electric and manual – phillips & regular). Also scrapers, wire brush, sand paper, electric grinder, paint containers, rollers, roller handles, roller pans, brushes, fast mask, clean up pans or buckets, and water.

    Get set by preparing surfaces to receive the paint. Removing any loose rust, blistering or loose paint with wire brush and scraping tool is a good “get set” start. I suggest doing any sand blasting after this, but ahead of removing dirt, mold and mildew, and other debris. The sand blasting will do some of removal for you. Sometimes I use air under pressure to remove dust and dirt. But there will be a clinging dust that will have to be brushed away with fine bristle brush or wiped away with rags. Any loose fasteners should be removed or secured. I usually replace loose nails with screws and where appropriate I use screws with neoprene washers. Neoprene washers exhibits good chemical stability and maintains flexibility over a wide temperature range helping to reduce leaking. Don’t forget your protective clothing, mask, and goggles.

  14. Hello, after reading this remarkable article
    i am also delighted to share my know-how here with mates.

  15. hello!,I really like your writing so a lot! proportion we communicate extra about your post on AOL?
    I require a specialist in this area to unravel my problem.
    May be that’s you! Looking forward to look you.

  16. I blog frequently and I seriously thank you for your information. This
    great article has truly peaked my interest. I will take a note of your website and keep
    checking for new details about once per week. I opted in for your Feed as well.

  17. I do agree with all the concepts you’ve introduced on your post.

    They’re really convincing and can certainly work. Still, the posts are too quick for newbies.
    May just you please lengthen them a little from subsequent time?

    Thank you for the post.

Leave a Reply